Call (305) 243-3000

Patient education · Knee

Partial vs total knee replacement

Michele R. D’Apuzzo, MD, is a University of Miami hip and knee surgeon. He sees patients at Tower West in Miami and SoLé Mia in North Miami. This page compares a partial knee replacement and a total knee replacement. It is education, not a diagnosis. Imaging and an exam decide, not this page. Many people still need a total knee.

UHealth Tower West

1321 NW 14th St, Suite 306
Miami, FL 33125

(305) 243-3000

UHealth SoLé Mia

2111 Sole Mia Way, 3rd Floor
North Miami, FL 33181

(305) 243-3000

Book at UHealth

Two ways to replace worn knee surfaces

The knee has three compartments: the inner side, the outer side, and the area under the kneecap. Arthritis can wear one part or more than one part.

  • In a partial knee replacement, only the worn compartment is resurfaced. Metal and a medical-grade plastic spacer take the place of those worn surfaces. The rest of the joint, and the ligaments that are still suitable, are kept.
  • In a total knee replacement, the worn ends of the thigh bone (femur) and the shin bone (tibia) are covered with new surfaces. Dr. D’Apuzzo resurfaces the undersurface of the kneecap in every total knee replacement he performs.

Why the kneecap? Data from the Australian joint replacement registry looked at more than 570,000 total knees for up to 17 years. Knees where the kneecap was resurfaced had a lower rate of needing another operation than knees where it was not. That is registry data across many people. It is not a promise for your knee.

AAOS patient education describes a partial as an option when disease is limited to one area of the knee. A total is the usual operation when more of the knee is worn, or when a partial is not a safe fit.

Neither operation is “half a surgery” or a smaller-scar promise. A partial is an implant choice. It does not guarantee less pain or a faster calendar than a total. If a total is the honest operation, that is the conversation.

When each one may be discussed

AAOS says you may not be a candidate for a partial knee if you have inflammatory arthritis, significant stiffness, or ligament damage. The arthritis must be limited to one compartment. Ligaments have to be suitable. Pain in more than one part of the knee often points to a total instead.

There is no single age cutoff. AAOS treats this as a shared decision after an exam and imaging, not a choice based on age alone.

Many people still need a total. AAHKS patient education notes that a total is the more common operation in the United States. A website cannot tell you which one you need.

For many people, conservative care comes first: activity changes, physical therapy, medicines, or injections. Surgery is not the first step for everyone.

What sources say — and what they do not promise

AAOS and AAHKS patient pages list possible advantages for people who truly qualify for a partial. Those lists can include a shorter hospital stay, less blood loss, and a quicker return to activity. Some people also report that the knee feels more natural.

Those points are general education. They are not a promise for your surgery. Results vary. If a total is needed, choosing a partial would not be a shortcut.

AAOS clinical guidance notes a tradeoff for some people. These are people with wear mainly on the inner side of the knee who could have either operation. Short-term comfort and function can be better after a partial. But the long-term chance of needing another operation may be higher than after a total. AAHKS makes the same point. A partial keeps more of your own knee. Arthritis can still develop in the parts that were not replaced. If a partial later fails, it can often be converted to a total. That second operation can be more involved. It is not a reason to choose a partial if a total is the better fit now.

Activity limits are similar after a partial and after a total. Neither is designed for high-impact sports such as running or jumping. Your own limits are set in clinic.

The robot is a tool, not a type of knee replacement

A robotic arm is used for many first-time total knees. Whether a partial knee is done with the robot is decided case by case. In either operation, Dr. D’Apuzzo stays in control. The robot does not operate on its own. It does not guarantee less pain or a faster recovery.

Read the procedure pages for how each operation is planned: partial knee replacement and robotic knee replacement. For who may be evaluated, see am I a candidate for robotic knee replacement?.

Recovery is a pathway, not a race between the two operations

You stand and walk when you are medically ready. Same-day discharge is discussed only when your health and home setup allow. Pain care is opioid-sparing, not opioid-free. See outpatient joint replacement, what a rapid recovery pathway is, and what opioid-sparing pain control means.

Question, then procedure, then campus, then call

Start with this comparison. Then read the procedure page that fits the plan you are discussing. Then pick a campus: Tower West or SoLé Mia. Then call, or book at UHealth. Read more about Dr. D’Apuzzo.

Both campuses are primary. There is no “main office.” Tower West serves Downtown and Midtown Miami. SoLé Mia serves North Miami, Aventura, and southern Broward.

Monday–Friday, 8:00am–4:30pm. After hours (urgent, not 911): (305) 243-1000. Emergency: 911.

Questions

Common questions

What is the difference between a partial and a total knee replacement?

A partial resurfaces only the worn part of the knee and keeps the rest of the joint. A total covers the worn ends of the thigh bone and the shin bone. Dr. D’Apuzzo also resurfaces the undersurface of the kneecap in every total knee he performs.

Who might be discussed for a partial knee?

It may be discussed when arthritis is limited to one compartment and the ligaments are suitable. AAOS lists poor fits such as inflammatory arthritis, significant stiffness, or ligament damage. Imaging and an exam decide. Many people still need a total.

Is a partial always better if only one part of the knee hurts?

No. Pain in one area does not automatically mean a partial is the right operation. This page cannot assign that choice.

Does a partial guarantee less pain or a faster recovery?

No. AAOS and AAHKS describe possible advantages for people who qualify. Those are not promises. A partial is not a smaller-scar or faster-calendar guarantee.

Is there an age cutoff for a partial knee?

No. There is no single age cutoff. The choice is made after an exam and imaging, not on age alone.

Are activity limits different after a partial and a total?

No. Limits are similar after either one. Neither is designed for high-impact sports such as running or jumping. Your own limits are set in clinic.

Do you use the robot for a partial knee?

Whether a partial knee is done with the robot is decided case by case. The robot is used for many first-time total knees. The surgeon stays in control.

Where do I call about a partial or total knee visit in Miami?

Call (305) 243-3000 for either campus. After hours (urgent, not 911): (305) 243-1000. For an emergency, call 911. You can also book at UHealth.

Educational information. Not medical advice. Not a diagnosis. Medically reviewed by Michele R. D’Apuzzo, MD, November 18, 2026.

Call or book

Tower West or SoLé Mia.

Monday–Friday, 8:00am–4:30pm. After hours (urgent, not 911): (305) 243-1000.

Patient education · All treatments · The surgeon

Call (305) 243-3000 Book at UHealth